Garden Organic, the national charity for organic growing, has given a cautious welcome to the new EU seed directive as a “step in the right direction” but with a need for “vigilance in the future” after fears the proposals would put plant biodiversity at risk.
The new Regulation on Marketing of Plant Reproductive Material (PRM), which was made public on Monday 6 May by the EU, exempts local heritage seed networks such as Garden Organic’s unique Heritage Seed library allowing seed exchange between individuals and groups. The new directive also identifies for the first time a need for more relaxed registration rules for heritage varieties and conservation varieties including land races – with all such categories being exempt from the testing or other requirements for the legislation.
The Directive will be restricted to commercial growers and home gardeners will be permitted to save and swap unapproved seed. Individuals and small organisations will also be able to grow and supply/sell unapproved vegetable seed – as long as they have less than 10 employees and an annual turnover of less than 2m euros.
It marks a significant change from the initial drafts of the directive as lobbying across Europe from concerned organisations such as Garden Organic has impacted upon the commission. In November 2012, DG SANCO (the EU Directorate responsible for health and consumer affairs) issued an updated draft proposal for a new Plant Reproductive Material (PRM) Regulation which sought to replace numerous directives in favour of the large seed houses preventing gardeners and farmers from exchanging seeds and growing heritage varieties.
This led to fears that seed exchange networks such as Garden Organic’s Heritage Seed Library and the swapping of seeds between private individuals would be subject to prohibitively costly annual licensing fees. This would have huge financial implications for facilities such as the Heritage Seed Library and small-scale professional seed suppliers, with the potential to put them out of business.
Bret Willers, Development Director at Garden Organic, said: “We welcome the news that the EU has seen sense and chosen not to include the Heritage Seed Library and small scale seed exchange networks within this legislation.
“It’s very much a step in the right direction from the EU but we must be vigilant for the future to ensure there is no backtracking to some of the original and more draconian proposals.
“It would that appear that through the vigilance and constant campaigning of organisations such as Garden Organic, we have been able to get the EU to take on these concerns and reflect them in the final draft of the directive.
“We must now continue to work to ensure that there are no further changes to the directive and that our rights to freely swap seed and protect our plant biodiversity remains enshrined in law for the future.”
Despite the key concessions made in the new directive, other parts of the Plant Reproductive Material Law are quite restrictive and in the long run could make it much harder for people to get hold of good seeds they want to grow at home. There are also clauses that mean the key concessions agreed could be removed in the future without coming back to the Parliament for a vote.
It reaffirms the need for vigilance with the next steps involving the directive going to the European Parliament for modification or approval from MEPS, with scope for changes for the better or for worse. Garden Organic will continue to campaign and lobby to ensure that the key amendments remain in place.
Gardeners can help support Garden Organic’s vital vegetable variety conservation work by joining the Heritage Seed Library. Membership gives access annually to up to six varieties from the HSL catalogue, which each year features around 200 of the 800 varieties in the collection. From 2013 this now includes exotic crop varieties gathered in through the Sowing New Seeds project.
For more information about the Heritage Seed Library, visit: www.gardenorganic.org.uk/hsl
For more information on Garden Organic’s Fighting Fund and campaigning activity go to: www.gardenorganic.org.uk/support_us/fightingfund.php
(Original article from Garden Organic website: here)

